By Christine Thomas
Special to The Advertiser
"Real" life suburban dramas are ubiquitous across television today, viewers relishing the scandals and pettiness simmering inside picture-perfect, cookie-cutter exterior worlds. It's both timely and bold, then, that Chris McKinney's latest novel, "Mililani Mauka," bounces off that exact framework skewed, of course, to McKinney's brand of dark, underbelly portraits of contemporary Hawai'i - delving into lives upturned instead of buoyed by O'ahu's false suburban promises.
It's a physical landscape rich with metaphorical promise, and McKinney mines it immediately with a disturbing prologue depicting John Krill (who later questionably appears as an edgy menehune ghost) bulldozing Mililani Town until shot by police. This scene signals an admirable and ambitious intention to tackle head on the growing resentment toward economically motivated priorities while Island problems like poverty and homelessness are largely ignored; yet whereas in previous books McKinney has proved he can tell a simply engaging story, here his narrative chops may have bitten off more than they can successfully chew.
Instead of centering on one fully developed perspective, McKinney spreads out, employing a limited third-person narration focused equally on three people. The first is Banyan Mott, a Honolulu Community College English professor (like McKinney), who "cheered that bulldozer on without knowing why." He lives in the same Mililani home where the other two narrators Kai Krill and her son Josh resided before Krill's rampage sent them living on the beach.
Banyan's narrative echoes his miserable marriage to a wife who, unlike him, loves the "suburban platonic orgy" and, incredibly, one night drinks two bottles of wine herself just one of several ill-fitting details, especially here for a functioning nurse and obsessive-compulsive mother. And when, midway through, McKinney lets slip additional minutiae such as Banyan's recent eyebrow ring, its late timing is puzzling, and instead of unpeeling deeper personality layers, anchors Banyan's portrait in two dimensions.
When Kai interacts with Banyan, whom she secretly meets in class at HCC while homeless, she morphs into a confident and centered woman, at once worldly and naive not at all as she appears in her sections; but these discrepancies are never addressed and thus can't add depth or understanding. Even more unsettling, Kai mainly thinks and acts like a man, never taking a clear shape.
Josh is the most rounded character and his sections are more powerful, which gives the novel breathing room even though he sometimes sounds like Banyan and other times a small child or a hardened teen mainly because they contain natural reflection about his yearnings, parents' failing marriage, mother's neglect and father's love, and insight into other characters, not just numb action and tunnel vision. Even though McKinney purposefully crafts all characters as lost and wounded, in Josh's sections he includes what's needed in Banyan's and Kai's developing strength and redeeming qualities that make the reader invested.
In addition to some strained interactions and unnatural dialogue, largely hampering successful dramatization is McKinney's teacherly instinct, persistently driving home the message that was clear from the first pages Hawai'i has changed, and become materially and spiritually poor. But the plot doesn't delve pointedly into "(t)he poverty (that) seems almost computer-generated on what would otherwise be a picture of tropical paradise," and instead sketches a landscape of artificial exteriors and unfulfilling lives that aren't so much unique to Hawai'i as they are domestic and human if also Western and an all too familiar story well beyond our shores.
In the end, the characters remain trapped in McKinney's metaphorical suburbs, their troubles palpable even after moving to "real" neighborhoods. And though Kai and Banyan banter wittily in response to another character's clunky query " 'So when did Hawai'i stop being Hawai'i?' " they don't seem to accept their participation in Hawai'i now.
Instead, they destroy or leave behind what they don't like, and try to be happy with what's left, which isn't much leaving readers to decide how inevitable change can be shaped for the better.