honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Sunday, January 11, 2009

CONTRACTS UP FOR BID
4 new rail contracts to cost $1B

By Sean Hao
Advertiser Staff Writer

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

The Bombardier train uses the same steel wheel on steel rail technology that Honolulu's elevated commuter train project will employ. The city this year will solicit bids for contracts worth about $1 billion; it already has awarded more than $100 million in deals since 2005.

ADVERTISER LIBRARY PHOTO | March 11, 2008

spacer spacer

WHO’S GETTING THE CONTRACTS

This year, the city will put out for bid four major transit-related contracts valued at about $1 billion:

  • Undetermined amount to conduct a risk management feasibility study. Contract to be awarded next month.

  • $550 million to $600 million to design and build an elevated six-mile guideway from East Kapolei to Leeward Community College. Contract to be awarded late this year.

  • $250 million for rail vehicle and systems. Contract to be awarded early next year.

  • $120 million to build a maintenance and storage facility. Contract to be awarded early next year.

  • spacer spacer

    CONTRACTS IN THE BAG

    So far the city has awarded three major train contracts worth about $108 million:

    ITEM: $10.2 million

    PURPOSE: Study mass-transit alternatives and

    environmental impacts

    NO. OF BIDDERS: 2

    WINNING BIDDER: Parsons Brinckerhoff

    LOSING BIDDER: Earth Tech Inc.

    DATE AWARDED: August 2005

    ITEM: $11.5 million over 2› years

    PURPOSE: To provide project management support on the preliminary engineering and environmental impact statement

    NO. OF BIDDERS: 2

    WINNING BIDDER: InfraConsult LLC (a new company formed by three former Parsons Brinckerhoff employees)

    LOSING BIDDER: Parsons Corp., which has no connection to Parsons Brinckerhoff

    DATE AWARDED: March 2007

    ITEM: $86 million over 2› years

    PURPOSE: To conduct preliminary engineering and environmental impact studies

    NO. OF BIDDERS: 2

    WINNING BIDDER: PB Americas Inc., a unit of Parsons Brinckerhoff

    LOSING BIDDER: Louis Berger Group Inc.

    DATE AWARDED: August 2007

    HOW CONTRACTS ARE AWARDED

    1. City places announcement on Internet or city Web site.

    2. Bidding closes about one month after announcement.

    3. A panel of city and industry officials rank bidders based on advertised criteria.

    spacer spacer

    The city plans to solicit bids for about $1 billion in contracts this year as part of an ambitious plan to start construction of an elevated commuter train in December.

    The first of those contracts is scheduled to be awarded next month and involves conducting a risk management feasibility study for the $5.3 billion, 20-mile train, according to a recently released bid solicitation. The value of that contract has not been decided. However, the biggest transit-related contract so far will come late this year and is expected to be a $550 million to $600 million deal to design and build an elevated six-mile guideway from East Kapolei to Leeward Community College. That excludes an unspecified amount to cover contingency costs.

    Other major transit contracts scheduled to be put out for bid this year include a $250 million rail vehicle and systems contract and a $120 million contract to build a maintenance and storage facility. Both contracts won't be awarded until early 2010.

    Those procurements are part of a plan to launch limited train service in phases starting in late 2013 and ending in late 2018. The success of that plan hinges in part on whether the Honolulu City Council fixes a glitch that's preventing the city from moving ahead with a construction contract. That could occur late this month.

    SEARCH FOR BIDDERS

    The first contract that will be awarded will be to conduct a risk assessment and implementation plan for the transit project, according to a request for proposals issued Dec. 31. Interested parties have until Feb. 3 to submit proposals and the city expects to award the contract on Feb. 27.

    The chosen contractor will advise the city as it solicits bidders for bigger contracts later this year, said Wayne Yoshioka, director of the city's Department of Transportation Services.

    "It's the normal thing you would need to set up for a project of this nature," he said. "If we do get to the point where we start construction, we want to make sure we've got this service on board."

    How many companies seek the initial contract along with their identities remains to be seen. So far, the city has awarded three major transit deals valued at about $108 million. In each instance, only two qualified proposals were submitted. That has prompted criticism the city hasn't done enough to promote more competition.

    Typically, the city posts procurement notices on the Internet then provides a one-month window for interested parties to submit proposals. That's the minimum posting requirement for contracts, according to the State Procurement Office. The city won't be varying from that practice with the new procurements.

    "Those who are interested already know to be looking (on the Internet), so it's very common for them to know where to look," Yoshioka said.

    REVISING ORDINANCE

    Among the companies not expected to bid on the risk assessment contract is New York-based transportation engineering consultant Parsons Brinckerhoff. The company already has been awarded two deals valued at more than $96 million to provide engineering and environmental studies on the transit project.

    Tadahiko Ono, a vice president for Parsons Brinckerhoff, said the company would not be bidding on the contract because that work should be done by a company not already directly involved in the project.

    The biggest contract so far on Honolulu's largest public works project ever is expected to be awarded once the federal government approves the project's environmental impact statement. City officials hope that will happen this fall so that construction can begin in December.

    The project's timetable also hinges on the City Council fixing a technical glitch that's preventing the solicitation of proposals to begin construction of the first phase. Legally, the city has been advised not to solicit bids for any construction contracts until the City Council alters the original ordinance authorizing the city to build the train.

    That measure required the administration to seek council approval before soliciting proposals to build the train system. That was added as an attempt to keep the council and public informed about key project details. However, that provision also violates state procurement laws, according to the state Procurement Office.

    ALTERNATIVE APPROACH

    Bill 63 would eliminate that provision and allow the city administration to seek construction proposals without council approval, but that issue also isn't expected to be resolved until Jan. 28 at the earliest.

    The City Council also has yet to resolve whether the train's route should traverse Salt Lake as planned or be diverted to pass by the industrial airport district.

    Under current plans, the first construction deal — valued at up to $600 million excluding contingencies — will be a design and build contract, which means the team selected only will be responsible for designing and building the first six miles of elevated guideway. That deal will be followed by separate contracts for vehicles and systems and for a maintenance yard.

    Currently, the city plans to operate the train system, though that can change between now and late 2013 when limited service is set to begin. Full service is scheduled to start by 2019.

    At least one City Council member thinks the city is taking the wrong approach by soliciting several, individual transit contracts.

    Councilman Donovan Dela Cruz last week introduced a resolution urging the city to enter into a design, build, operate and maintain contract for the rail project. One big contract could allow the city to fix the cost of construction early, while placing the risk of cost overruns and delays on the contractor.

    "I'm not against the concept of rail," Dela Cruz said. "I'm against how it's being implemented.

    "I believe in looking at all the different scenarios across the country that design, build, operate and maintain is the best thing."

    The city's Wayne Yoshioka defended the city's approach of breaking up the transit contracts.

    "We're doing that to boost competition and participation," he said. "If we do one humongous contract, there are only a few companies that have the wherewithal to go after something that huge. What it would do is reduce the number of firms that would be involved," Yoshioka said.

    Reach Sean Hao at shao@honoluluadvertiser.com.