honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Friday, April 4, 2008

A 'Sweeney Todd' gore fest

By Jen Chaney
Washington Post

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Johnny Depp is the monstrously depraved barber and Helena Bonham Carter is his sadistic muse in "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street." The collector's edition is worth the few extra bucks.

Leah Gallo

spacer spacer

As Johnny Depp explains on the DVD of "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street," he had never sung a note in his life until he decided to take the starring role in the movie version of one of the most revered musicals from one of theater's most renowned composers, Stephen Sondheim. You have to hand it to Depp. The guy never does anything halfway.

His brave move paid off. "Sweeney" not only earned the unconventional actor his third Oscar nomination, it proved that the former guitarist for the band The Kids has a raw, evocative singing voice. (Some compare it to David Bowie's, but I say he strikes more of a Peter Murphy note.)

But as believably brooding as Depp may be, the man ultimately responsible for the success of "Sweeney Todd," arriving on DVD this week in both a standard and two-disc collector's edition, is director Tim Burton. In this savage story about a barber who murders his clients and, with the help of the sadistic Mrs. Lovett (Helena Bonham Carter), bakes them into meat pies, Burton has found the sort of off-center, dark material that suits his sensibilities perfectly. He creates a Victorian-era London awash in shadows and deep sepia tones, but often brightened by the crimson splash of fresh blood and the sound of beautiful music. It is easily the most accomplished, sophisticated work the director has committed to film so far; even Sondheim himself, who appears numerous times on the DVD's extras, gives this "Sweeney" his seal of approval.

Of course, there are plenty of people who simply won't care for "Sweeney Todd." If you dislike musical theater, Burton's films, Bonham Carter when she's wearing freaky eye shadow or even the slightest trickle of plasma, then skip this movie. Hard-core fans of the Depp-Burton canon and Sondheim, however, will enjoy that collector's edition, which offers enough decent extras to merit the few extra bucks it costs. (The basic DVD comes with just a single, albeit well-done, half-hour documentary.)

The numerous featurettes delve into great detail about the history behind the original demon barber legend, Sondheim's show and Burton's movie. Others dance into related territory, like "Grand Guignol: A Theatrical Tradition," a look at how the horror plays from turn-of-the-20th-century Paris influenced "Sweeney Todd" as well as other contemporary motion pictures. ("Films like the 'Saw' trilogy and 'Hostel' are very clearly in the tradition of Grand Guignol theater," explains a college professor. And here you thought they were just exploitative gore fests out to make a quick buck.)

Half of the bonus features are worth watching, while the rest — such as a taped press conference and the dippy making-of featurette — are mostly fluff. It's too bad there is no commentary track from, say, Burton and Sondheim or footage of Sacha Baron Cohen's audition for the part of Pirelli. According to Burton and producer Richard Zanuck, the man who gave birth to Borat tried out for the part by crooning an abridged version of "Fiddler on the Roof." Now that's something I would pay to see.

Most Hemoglobin-Rich Bonus: The featurette "A Bloody Business" reveals the machinery involved in making those barbershop slices spew so convincingly. A member of the prosthetics team gamely dons a fake neck and chest, which is connected to a series of pumps, and lets a colleague pretend-slit his throat. His reaction after all that fake blood drenches his shirt? "Ooh, that's cold."

The following DVDs are scheduled for release next week.

  • "Lions for Lambs" (R, 88 minutes): In this impassioned but strangely inert current events drama directed by Robert Redford, Tom Cruise plays a fictional Republican U.S. senator named Jasper Irving. For all its passion and topical currency, the movie plays too often like a college colloquium. Contains war violence and profanity. DVD extras: commentary, featurettes, trailers.

  • "Music Within" (R, 94 minutes): Ron Livingston plays Richard Pimentel, a real-life activist who was instrumental in the passage of the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990. Unfortunately, Livingston's character is a schematic creation whose indefatigable spirit seems only a minor foible or two short of sainthood. Contains sexual references and drug use. DVD extras: commentary, deleted scenes.

  • "P2" (R, 98 minutes): Cheerfully manipulative, this is the kind of suspense flick that invites audiences to yell back at the screen and cheer. Contains graphic violence and subject matter, and strong language. DVD extras: commentary, featurettes.

  • "Reservation Road" (R, 103 minutes): Director Terry George of "Hotel Rwanda" fame evokes a two-family tragedy with great clarity, and the terrible pain that follows with equal clarity. But the movie, starring Joaquin Phoenix, Jennifer Connelly and Mark Ruffalo, soon veers toward thriller junk. Contains profanity and violence. DVD extras: featurettes, deleted scenes.

  • "Resurrecting the Champ" (PG-13, 111 minutes): The story of a sportswriter (Josh Hartnett) who discovers his ticket to the big leagues in the form of a big, fat story. Then a trick of fate intervenes, and his ride to the top may turn out to be a one-way to the bottom unless he learns to fake contrition and humility fast. Contains violence and brief language. DVD extras: interviews with the cast.

  • "There Will Be Blood" (R, 158 minutes): Another astonishing performance from Oscar winner Daniel Day-Lewis, who in the film's silent opening moments even breathes with eerie authenticity. Contains violence. DVD extras: featurettes, deleted scenes, trailers, pictures and research.

  • "Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story" (R, 98 minutes): This parody skewers the most cherished tropes of Hollywood biopics. It all sounds good on paper, and there are some hilarious moments, but the movie comes up with only a few genuine gems. Contains sexual content, graphic nudity, drug use and profanity. DVD extras: commentary, featurettes, deleted and extended scenes, full song performances, song demos, CoxSausage commercial with outtakes.