honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, June 8, 2009

Motorcycle-related deaths continue to climb in Hawaii


By Michael Tsai
Advertiser Staff Writer

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

A motorcyclist was killed and another injured in a collision with a van on Kailua Road in April (below). A memorial honors the man who died, Eric Souza.

RICHARD AMBO | The Honolulu Advertiser

spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Advertiser library photo

spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser
spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Charles Costa describes finding Wayne Medeiros Jr. after the motorcyclist crashed into this guardrail the night of Jan. 1 in Waipahu.

Advertiser library photo

spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Honolulu firefighters clean up a section of Farrington Highway in Ma'ili after motorcyclist Wesley Garcia was killed in an accident with a school bus in February. Garcia, of Wai'anae, was 44.

Advertiser library photo

spacer spacer

Despite calls for motorcyclists and drivers of four-wheeled vehicles to safely share the road, the number of motorcycle-related fatalities in Hawai'i continues to climb.

The death of rider Steve Donohue, 43, following a Friday night crash brought the state- wide total to 21 motorcycle-related deaths so far this year, compared with seven at the same point last year.

The number of motorcycle-related deaths on Hawai'i roadways has risen in five of the last six years. Last year's total of 32 set a record for motorcycle fatalities in the state and ranked Hawai'i No. 3 in the nation in motorcycle-related fatalities per capita last year.

The previous high was 29 in 1994, according to data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

It's a dubious record that could be smashed this year if the number of fatalities from the first six months of 2009 doubles by the end of the year.

The figures, compiled by the state Department of Transportation, do not account for fatalities that occur away from public roads. According to Advertiser archives, there have been at least three additional motorcycle-related deaths this year: an 82-year-old man killed when he lost control of a motorcycle while riding on a service road at Dillingham Airfield, a 36-year-old man who died after crashing down an embankment off Pi'ilani Highway on Maui and a motorcyclist who died on a trail above Kahuku Motocross Track.

DOT officials, motorcycle club members and others who have tracked the expanding roster of lost lives are at a loss to explain the recent spike.

While many cite increases in the number of new riders and the overall number of motorcycles on the road, motorcycle sales nationally have been in decline since 2007 and have plummeted by more than 30 percent in the first quarter of 2009, according to the Motorcycle Industry Council.

In 2008, there were 28,447 registered motorcycles in Hawai'i, 19,964 of them on O'ahu, according to the DOT.

Recent increases in motorcycle fatalities have also been popularly attributed in part to military personnel returning from deployment overseas.

However, over the last few years, the various armed forces have been aggressive in addressing perceived problems with returning troops purchasing motorcycles — typically high-performance sport bikes — and riding irresponsibly.

Some bases require troops who ride motorcycles to regularly attend experienced-rider classes. The Army has also instituted a policy, applied differently from base to base, requiring motorcycle riders returning from deployment to attend refresher courses before they can return to riding.

FACTORS IN ACCIDENTS

When motorcycle accident figures followed motorcycle sales upward at the start of the decade, some attributed the increase to baby boomers learning or re-learning how to ride on large Harley-Davidson-style cruisers. Yet, there has been only one officially recorded motorcycle fatality in Hawai'i this year involving an operator older than 50.

Of the 18 fatal motorcycle accidents for which the DOT has cited related causes, eight were found to have been speed related, seven involved another vehicle turning left in front of the oncoming motorcycle and two involved alcohol use on the part of the motorcycle operator. The narrow front profile of a motorcycle can make it difficult for drivers to accurately determine distance and speed, a key factor in many accidents initiated when a car turns or changes lanes in front of a motorcycle.

Motorcycle safety instructor Bill Labby said that when he approaches an intersection on a motorcycle, he first slows to assess the situation, then accelerates once he's sure it's safe. If there is a car or truck across the way, he tries to make eye contact to ensure that the driver sees him. If there's any chance that the car might cut in front of him, signal or no signal, he'll stop or pull over.

"In that situation, if someone is going to cut you off, you can either hit the brakes or accelerate and get out of the way," he said. "But you have to be in one of those two modes. Of course, you can't anticipate every situation. If someone is stupid and they gun it in front of you, you crash and become part of the statistics."

Two weeks ago, Thomas Reimer, 36, and his 7-year-old son Thomas Reimer Jr., were killed when their 2006 Suzuki motorcycle collided with a car that was attempting a left turn from Route 130 onto Ainaloa Boulevard on the Big Island. The driver of the car, Bobby Jiminez, 21, was arrested on two counts of negligent homicide and other charges.

On April 26, Eric Souza, 36, was killed when a rental van driven by Japanese tourist Jiro Matsunaga veered suddenly from the right lane to the left lane of Kailua Road in an attempt to make a U-turn. Souza, who was at the front of a group of five riders in the left lane, collided with the van. A second rider, a 43-year-old man, also hit the van and was hospitalized in critical condition. Matsunaga was later charged with third-degree negligent homicide and first-degree negligent injury.

Motorcyclist Jim Barnes, 51, of Kaimuki, said he has had numerous close calls with cars turning left in front of him at intersections.

"People will cut you off because they aren't paying attention, they don't understand that motorcycles are less stable and more vulnerable than cars, or they just don't care," Barnes said. "That's the sad part. Sometimes, even if you make eye contact, they'll still cut you off."

'SHARE THE ROAD'

Nationally, motorcycle fatalities have increased every year for the last 12 years, from 2,116 in 1997 to 5,357 in 2008, according to the NHTSA. The increase in fatalities outpaced the increase in the number of registered motorcycles in the United States, from 3.8 million in 1997 to 7.1 million last year (with sales of all two-wheelers estimated at more than 1 million last year).

The increase in motorcycle fatalities here and around the country hasn't gone unnoticed. Last month, the DOT joined transportation departments around the country in promoting a "Share the Road" message to riders and driver. Public service announcements began last week and will continue through the summer. A safety rally is also scheduled for July 4.

In February, the Honolulu Police Department called on Hawai'i drivers to operate their vehicles with extra caution because of the high number of fatalities early in the year. At the time, six motorcyclists had died in accidents, including a 29-year-old man who collided with a van that had made a left turn in front of him.

But collisions with other vehicles are only part of the problem. Over the ensuing month and a half after the HPD caution, six of seven motorcycle fatalities came in single-vehicle accidents, each involving excessive speed, loss of control or both.

Most recently, speed was cited by police as an apparent factor in the death of Donohue, son of former Honolulu Police Chief Lee Donohue, on Friday. According to police, Donohue lost control of his 2004 Suzuki motorcycle while attempting to exit the H-1 Freeway at the Wilder Street off-ramp.

Labby said that, all things considered, Hawai'i riders are at no greater risk than riders in other states. While local drivers may be notorious for not using turn signals to indicate their intentions, Labby said such potentially dangerous quirks are offset by "a real spirit of aloha."

"Here, if you want to get into a lane, people will let you in," he said. "In other states, they'll run you over and call your mother names."

Still, Labby said, riders and drivers alike can do much more to ensure their safety on the roads. In particular, he said, both need to remain aware of their surroundings at all times, ensure that their vehicles are properly maintained, and ride or drive within their limitations.

• • •


HOW TO AVOID 2 COMMON TYPES OF ACCIDENTS

Of the 21 fatal motorcycle accidents in Hawai'i this year, eight have involved the speed of the motorcycle and seven involved another car turning left in front of the motorcycle. In incidents involving excessive speed, many fatalities result from rapid-braking or turning accidents known as "highsiders."

Here's how to minimize your risk of being injured in these situations:

• Highsider


A highsider occurs when a rider puts excessive force on the rear brake (causing it to lock) or applies too much throttle while exiting a turn, causing the rear wheel to angle away from the line of travel. When the rear wheel regains traction in this position, the motorcycle straightens and the rider is most often thrown from the bike.

When braking suddenly, it is important to remember that as you decelerate, your center of gravity shifts forward. To account for this shift, use both your front and rear brakes simultaneously and your front brakes to do 70 percent of the stopping work. Be aware of the terrain beneath your front tire, as loose dirt or gravel could cause you to skid.

When exiting a turn, smoothly and gradually apply the throttle as the motorcycle straightens to a fully upright position. If your rear tire starts to slip as you accelerate, do not slow down, as this may cause the tire to regain traction at an off angle, resulting in a highsider. Instead, gently roll on the throttle until control is regained.

• Left turn by another vehicle


In a perfect world, every driver would clearly indicate intent to turn by using the turn signal and waiting for the intersection to clear before executing the move. However, drivers often misjudge the speed or distance of oncoming motorcycles (or wrongly assume that a motorcycle can stop as quickly and stably as a four-wheeled vehicle) and dart in front of a bike to make the turn.

To minimize this danger, move to the left side of your lane, downshift as you near the intersection, and try to make direct eye contact with the driver to ensure that you are seen. Also scan the surrounding area for a line of escape, should you need to accelerate out of the way. If you are unsure if the driver of the car facing you intends to turn, consider stopping or pulling over, even if you have the right of way. If you feel confident that the car is not going to turn, accelerate through the intersection but be prepared to either brake suddenly or accelerate out of the way should the car suddenly turn.

WHAT EVERY DRIVER, RIDER SHOULD KNOW

RIDERS

You're invisible: Never assume the other driver sees you.

Practice pays off: Performing an emergency maneuver on the road is usually a matter of executing everyday riding technique, just rapidly and with great precision. Practicing basic skills like pressing and leaning into turns, swerving at normal speeds and scanning for escape routes each time you ride will ensure you're prepared to deal with sudden and unexpected situations.

Choosing the right bike: Street bikes are designed to perform at high speeds, but they can be a deadly choice for those who lack the skills or experience to control them in an emergency. And while Harley-Davidson-style cruisers are built for comfort and stability, certain models may be too large or heavy for smaller riders to safely manage.

Helmets can help: The NHTSA and state DOT cite data that indicate helmets could have saved lives of riders in more than 30 percent of all fatal motorcycle accidents. In Hawai'i, they're required for riders 17 and younger.

DRIVERS

Turn signals aren't optional: Signaling your intentions when turning or changing lanes is common sense — and the law.

Motorcycles may be closer than you think: The narrow profile of a motorcycle can make it difficult for you to accurately gauge its speed and distance.

Motorcyclists need the whole lane: Riders frequently alternate between the left, right and center portions of their lane for maximum visibility and to navigate around road hazards. Never attempt to share a lane or cross a motorcycle's front or rear plane when changing lanes.

Motorcycles need time and space to stop: Motorcycles are less stable than four-wheeled vehicles, especially when forced to stop quickly.

Sources: Hawai'i Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Association, Motorcycle Safety Foundation, certified motorcycle instructor Bill Labby